“There is no medicine like hope, no incentive so great, and no tonic so powerful as expectation of something tomorrow.” Orison Swett Marden
“Hope sees the invisible, feels the intangible, and achieves the impossible.” Helen Keller
Introduction: Many of us take levodopa/carbidopa for substantial symptomatic relief; however, this dopamine replacement treatment only relieves symptoms without offering either neuroprotection or neuro-restoration. We are still anxiously waiting for the study to be released that announces “We describe a new Parkinson’s compound and we’ve nicknamed it hopeful, helpful, and protective“. Today’s post will review an interesting paper from Yuning Che and associates in Dalian, China recently published in Cell Death and Disease (open access, click here to download paper). The ‘hopeful’ neuroprotective compound is the amino sulfonic compound taurine. Before we get lost in all of the possibilities, let’s discuss the science and see what they describe, ok? First, we begin with some background.
“I truly believe in positive synergy, that your positive mindset gives you a more hopeful outlook, and belief that you can do something great means you will do something great.” Russell Wilson
Neuroinflammation and Oxidative Stress are Pathological Processes that Promote the Development of Parkinson’s: Parkinson’s is a neurodegenerative disorder where we lose dopamine-producing neurons in the mid-brain substantia nigra. There are several pathological patterns known to contribute to the development of Parkinson’s as highlighted below. Related to this post is the negative-effect contributed by long-term neuroinflammation and oxidative stress.
“It’s hope as a decision that makes change possible.” Jim Willis
Macrophages in the Brain are Called Microglia Cells: In many instances, the body initiates and uses the pro-inflammatory machinery as a host-defense response; in other words, we use it to protect ourselves. When it gets highjacked and becomes detrimental to the host, we realize the sheer firepower of our inflammatory system. The good-and-the-bad of inflammation is mediated primarily by the cells named neutrophils (along with the eosinophils and basophils), monocytes and macrophages. The monocyte leaves the bloodstream and migrates to various organs/tissues where it can ‘mature’ into a macrophage, which is a ‘field commander’ type-of-cell. Think of a macrophage as a General in the bunker of a battlefield, not only giving detailed marching orders but they are also leading the charging brigade of soldiers. Macrophages in the brain are named microglia cells. First, macrophages (microglia cells) are ‘phagocytic’ cells that are capable of engulfing foreign-damaged-invading substances/cells (phagocyte comes from the Greek phagein, “to eat” or “devour”, and “-cyte”, the suffix in biology denoting “cell”). Second, macrophages (microglia cells) direct the inflammatory response by releasing all kinds of substances that give other inflammatory/immune cells their instructions. Sometimes these cells and their instructions become bad to the neighboring tissue/organs; in our case, the dopamine-producing neurons in the midbrain.
Microglia-mediated neuroinflammation(Figure credit): Various substances initiate contact with resting unstimulated microglia cells. This ‘activates’ the microglia cell into a cell of considerable fire-power by producing and releasing many substances [nitric oxide (NO), reactive oxygen species (ROS), and several inflammatory cytokines (e.g., IL-1, IL-6, and TNF-alpha)]. This collection of pro-inflammatory substances secreted by the activated microglia cells creates a hostile microenvironment that promotes neuronal cell dysfunction and potential death to the cell.
Depending on the need and response of the ‘environmental challenge’, macrophages (microglia cells) can be activated to become either ‘M1’ (focused on becoming a pro-inflammatory) microglia cell or ‘M2’ (transforms into an anti-inflammatory) microglia cell [see Figure below, credit]. In the setting of an invasion or infiltration by microbes, you would want the microglia cell to be activated to a M1 state’ they could attack, engulf and kill the invading microorganism. In this setting, the M1 microglia cell would be protective of you. By contrast, the role of M2 microglia cells would be to turn-off the resultant pro-inflammatory response. This implies that long-term inflammatory events that promote inappropriate M1 microglia cell activation could lead to dysfunction and even cell/tissue death. This description of appropriate/inappropriate microglia cell activation illustrates the complex nature of these inflammatory cells. What this says is in Parkinson’s, chronic activation to M1 microglia cells could generate a detrimental neuroinflammatory environment able to attack host cells/tissues.
“It is difficult to say what is impossible, for the dream of yesterday is the hope of today and the reality of tomorrow.” Robert H. Goddard
Taurine: Taurine is an amino sulfonic compound (many erroneously use the term amino acid) and it is considered to be a conditionally essential nutrient. We do not use taurine in the assembly of proteins from genes; however, it participates in several physiological systems. Taurine is apparently a popular additive/supplement in many different energy drinks. Both WebMD (click here) and the Mayo Clinic (click here) have posted overviews of taurine and consider it mostly safe. The structure of taurine is shown below (credit). Taurine is found in the brain, heart, muscle and in many other organs. Good sources of dietary taurine are animal and fish proteins. An interesting overview for using taurine to stay healthy and to promote longevity has recently been posted (click here). Taurine has many proposed physiological functions that range from neurotransmitter to cell anti-oxidant, from anti-inflammatory to enhancing sports performance. The ‘problem’ with having a multi-talented substance like taurine is actually studying these diverse functions individually and trying to test them in rigorous scientific studies, which leads us (finally!) to the paper introduced at the beginning.
“Hope is the mainspring of life.” Henry L. Stimson
Taurine protects dopaminergic neurons in a mouse Parkinson’s disease model through inhibition of microglial M1 polarization: Here are some key aspects to this study:
- It is becoming more evident that neuroinflammation and oxidative stress are likely key participants in the development of Parkinson’s.
- Surrounding the substantia nigra are a lot of unactivated microglia cells, which when activated to become M1 microglia cells they secrete several cytotoxic compounds that can easily harm or kill dopaminergic-producing neurons.
- In particular, these neurons are susceptible to ‘injury’ due to their low antioxidant potential, low levels of calcium, increased amounts of iron, and the oxidation-susceptible dopamine.
- Taurine has been shown in several reports to be a neuromodulating substance, boosting intracellular levels of calcium, anti-oxidant, and anti-inflammatory.
- A recent report linked motor severity in Parkinson’s to low levels of taurine in blood plasma.
- The authors tested a hypothesis that the supplementation with exogenous taurine might be neuroprotective in a Parkinson’s model sy\stem.
- Previous studies have revealed a neuroprotective role for taurine in both glutamate-induced and hypoxic-ischemic brain models.
- They used a mouse model of Parkinson’s caused by injection with paraquat and maneb [(P + M) a two-pesticide model of Parkinson’s], which showed progressive dopaminergic neurodegeneration, gait abnormality, and α-synuclein aggregation.
- Taurine treatment protected the mouse from the detrimental effect of P + Mu.
- Their results revealed three effects of taurine in the P + M model of Parkinson’s (i) inhibition of microglia cell activation; (ii) reduced M1 microglia cell polarization; and (iii) reduced activation of cellular NOX2 and nuclear factor-kappa B (NF-κB).
“Losing the possibility of something is the exact same thing as losing hope and without hope nothing can survive.” Mark Z. Danielewski
Overview of Some of Their Results: Figure 1 presents the effect of P + M to promote a pathological state that resembles Parkinson’s. Panels 1A and 1B show the loss of dopaminergic neurons by the staining of the brain with an antibody to tyrosine hydroxylase (a major dopaminergic neuron protein) following P + M injection. Panels !C and 1D show that P + M treatment lead to the expression of the toxic oligomeric α-synuclein. Not shown here, but P + M treatment resulted in displayed abnormal gaits (Figure 2 in the paper).
Taurine protected against P + M-mediated neurotoxicity. Using the same tests as done in Figure 1 above, taurine preserved neurons even with P + M present (Figure 3 panels A and B) and taurine reduced expression of oligomeric α-synuclein in the presence of P + M (Figure 3 panels C and D). Not included here, the protective effects of taurine during P + M treatment was partly due to the inhibition of migroglia cell-mediated chronic inflammation. Furthermore, the ability of microglia cells to become ‘polarized’ or activated to either M1 (pro-inflammatory) or M2 (anti-inflammatory) was also studied in the presence of taurine plus P + M-treatment. Both M1 and M2 microglia cells are present in the mid-brain of the mice treated with P + M; interestingly, taurine treatment reduced expression levels of damaging M1 microglia cell products (results not included here). Finally, two key M1-linked gene products were studied, NOX2 and NF-kB. They found that taurine was able to reduce expression of both NOX2 and NF-kB, which indicates that taurine blocked these key products important for neuroinflammation (NOX2) and polarization of the M1 microglia cell-type (NF-kB)
“The present is the ever moving shadow that divides yesterday from tomorrow. In that lies hope.” Frank Lloyd Wright
What do these results show? (1) In an interesting model of Parkinson’s, taurine showed a potent benefit to the mice; (2) taurine reduced loss of dopamine-producing neurons in P + M mice; (3) taurine reduced oligomeric α-synuclein in P + M mice; (4) taurine treatment reduced neuroinflammation by suppressing M1 microglia cells to suggest a neuroprotective effect; and finally, (5) taurine reduced expression of both NOX2 and NF-kB, important genes for microglia cell activation. A similar neuroprotective effect was also found for taurine in an experimental model of Alzheimer’s disease, which resulted in improved cognitive ability. The Parkinson’s model clearly suggests that disease progression by P + M treatment is promoted by chronic neuroinflammation and M1-type microglia cells. Under the test conditions used, taurine was shown to convincingly reduce dopamine-producing neuronal cell degeneration in the presence of the pesticides P + M.
What do these results suggest? There is still much to learn about taurine. There is much potential to taurine being neuroprotective. However, there have been other seriously–convincing-positive mouse model results with other compounds that failed miserably in human clinical trials. The data shown here uses an interesting mouse model of Parkinson’s with a simple yet elegant and solid set of data (that does not appear to be overly interpreted). Taurine has been shown to be safe in treating other human maladies (diabetes and cardiovascular disease). The results here are hopeful that taurine could provide neuroprotection in human Parkinson’s. Hopefully, clinical trials will be started somewhere soon to determine the ability of taurine to provide neuroprotection in human Parkinson’s disease.
“Every one of us is called upon, perhaps many times, to start a new life. A frightening diagnosis, a marriage, a move, loss of a job…And onward full-tilt we go, pitched and wrecked and absurdly resolute, driven in spite of everything to make good on a new shore. To be hopeful, to embrace one possibility after another–that is surely the basic instinct…Crying out: High tide! Time to move out into the glorious debris. Time to take this life for what it is.” Barbara Kingsolver
Cover photo credit: wallpaper/nature/1024×768/Dawn_skies_over_Gulf_of_St._Lawrence_Prince_Edward_Island_Canada_1024x768.jpg
7 Replies to “Neuroprotection with Taurine in a Parkinson’s Model System”
I love your blog and posts and find them most informative. I believe maybe I posted here before, but I’m not sure hence my post today.
I believe people with late onset slow progressing neurological disorders whose etiology stems from misfolded proteins CAN take actions to slow the progression of their illness BECAUSE it is so slow BUT I also believe there will never be a “silver bullet” that can face the test of a gold standard double blind placebo controlled trial since the pathology of such diseases is myriad in it’s effects ALL of which must be remedied. In any case I hope you will take a moment to review what I am doing and consider the possibility of a multi-pronged approach to slowing the progression of PD:
I realize I do not have PD, but if you take a moment to study the illness you will find it is very similar and that is why I am constantly looking to PD research for new insight that may be helpful for SCA1. All the Best!
Joe in NY
P.S. Not meant as braggadocio, but just to say I am not without intelligence I was my High School valedictorian and graduated Dartmouth College Magna Cume Laude with an MBA/BSEE.
Ah, just looked back a couple post and saw I did post earlier so my apologies for forgetting. Again Best of Luck in your fight! Joe
Great to see the support of the concept of HOPE!
This also seems to entangle itself with “placebo”(nocebo – whatever we have these days?).
It’s common to focus on oxidation, although there seems to be almost as much requirement for the similar pathways involving nitrogen.
Frank Church | April 5, 2018 at 12:43 PM | Tags: Blog, Education, Health, Model System of Parkinson’s, Parkinson’s, Parkinson’s Disease, Science | Categories: Blog, Central Nervous System (CNS), Complementary and Alternative Medicine, Education, Education and Support, Health and Healing, Hope, Medicine, Model System, Neurodegenerative Disorders, Neuroscience, Parkinson’s, Parkinson’s Disease, Research | URL: https://wp.me/p5RiDc-7Au
David Ponsonby firstname.lastname@example.org
ai love your blog – it is so informative. Thank you for all of your scholarly research. I am always looking for alternative treatments. I may of missed it, but is there a particular dosage of taurine that helps with neuroprotection.
Hello nicce blog